Fischer up, Morphy down
Bobby Fischer - 28
Emanuel Lasker - 27
Paul Morphy - 28
Wilhelm Steinitz - 18
Jose Capablanca - 29
Anatoly Karpov - 26
Garry Kasparov - 19
Mikhail Tal - 19
Mikhail Botvinnik - 19
Vishy Anand - 28
Tigran Petrosian - 18
Francois-Andre Philidor - 24
Howard Staunton - 3
Boris Spassky - 14
Down Staunton, up Capablanca
Bobby Fischer - 28
Emanuel Lasker - 27
Paul Morphy - 28
Wilhelm Steinitz - 18
Jose Capablanca - 30
Anatoly Karpov - 26
Garry Kasparov - 19
Mikhail Tal - 19
Mikhail Botvinnik - 19
Vishy Anand - 28
Tigran Petrosian - 18
Francois-Andre Philidor - 24
Howard Staunton - 1
Boris Spassky - 14
Capablanca slowly becomes a silent winner while we fight over Fischer vs. Morphy. This is still the lesser evil for me, because I'm ok with Capablanca.
Up Kasparov, up Magnus Carlsen and up Vishy Anand.
Can't the 3 people doing the voting get this settled?
Going off of LeoPocci's comment...
Up Kasparov, Down Morphy
Bobby Fischer - 28
Emanuel Lasker - 27
Paul Morphy - 27
Wilhelm Steinitz - 18
Jose Capablanca - 30
Anatoly Karpov - 26
Garry Kasparov - 20
Mikhail Tal - 19
Mikhail Botvinnik - 19
Vishy Anand - 28
Tigran Petrosian - 18
Francois-Andre Philidor - 24
Howard Staunton - 1
Boris Spassky - 14
Fischer Up. Spassky Down. Added Efin Geller. (if you can, I can)
Bobby Fischer - 29
Emanuel Lasker - 27
Paul Morphy - 27
Wilhelm Steinitz - 18
Jose Capablanca - 30
Anatoly Karpov - 26
Ruy Lopez - 25
F'in Geller - 25
Garry Kasparov - 20
Mikhail Tal - 19
Mikhail Botvinnik - 19
Vishy Anand - 28
Tigran Petrosian - 18
Francois-Andre Philidor - 24
Howard Staunton - 1
Boris Spassky - 12
Morphy Up, Staunton down, and eliminated
Bobby Fischer - 29
Emanuel Lasker - 27
Paul Morphy - 28
Wilhelm Steinitz - 18
Jose Capablanca - 30
Anatoly Karpov - 26
Ruy Lopez - 25
F'in Geller - 25
Garry Kasparov - 20
Mikhail Tal - 19
Mikhail Botvinnik - 19
Vishy Anand - 28
Tigran Petrosian - 18
Francois-Andre Philidor - 24
Howard Staunton - 0 eliminated
Boris Spassky - 12
Adding
@Thezombieman's comment, (don't know who he down voted, but I'd say Kasparov on behalf of him)
Up Capablanca, down Morphy. Why are people so addicted to Morphy?
Bobby Fischer - 29
Emanuel Lasker - 27
Paul Morphy - 28
Wilhelm Steinitz - 18
Jose Capablanca - 30
Anatoly Karpov - 26
Ruy Lopez - 25
Garry Kasparov - 18
Mikhail Tal - 19
Mikhail Botvinnik - 19
Vishy Anand - 29
Tigran Petrosian - 18
Francois-Andre Philidor - 24
Boris Spassky - 12